[Superstar™]

Who do you think is the most overrated or underrated ?

IMO:

over - :

- cr7
- torres
- eto'o
- Dempsey
- barry ferguson (rangers dude)

under - :

- deco
- alex
- saha
- cissé
- gago

[jor]

over -

eto'o
lampard
ballack

[gb nine t]

I think Dempsey is underated if im honest Adu is overated.

Overated:

Ballack
Lampard
Walcott (I really hope that proves me wrong though)
Sergio Ramos

[cozz]

I wouldn't call Ronaldo or Eto'o overrated, they are both rated very highly but deservedly so.

I basically agree with Gav, really hope Walcott does well though. Sergio Ramos was incredibly over-priced (but everyone is nowadays) but he's done very well towards the end of the season.

[arsenal144]

i think lampard is extreamly over rated yeah he does the job at chelsea scoring goals but thats all he can do an for england he is shocking he shudnt even be in the squad

[Dave]

Originally Posted by ACH15.

Who do you think is the most overrated or underrated ?

IMO:

over - :
- barry ferguson (rangers dude)

You are such a liar


Over :
C.Ronaldo
Rooney
Hargreaves
Ronaldinho

Under:
Agger
Barry Ferguson

[dee brown]

Originally Posted by ACH15.

over - :

- cr7
- torres
- eto'o
- Dempsey
- barry ferguson (rangers dude)

Are you having a larf?

I'll start near at the top of the list, with Samuel Eto'o.

He has got to be one of the most, if not the slagged players in all of the European leagues, which makes me wonder how he can be overrated.

Secondly, be honest now, when have you seen Barry Ferguson play, or here anyone hype over Barry Ferguson, neither happen too often.

[5 Times]

over - :
Lampard
R.Ferdiand
Vidic
under - :
Carragher
Gilberto
d.Alves

[zaffo]

Originally Posted by ∂ιяк lfc кυут

over - :
Lampard
R.Ferdiand
Vidic
under - :
Carragher
Gilberto
d.Alves

Typical scouser.

How can a man who's bagged 20+ goals for like 4 years straight from Midfield be overrated? Not to mention he plays week in week out and a consistently high level. Hell he played poor for the 2nd half of the EPL last season and still managed 20 goals. While he also defends and tackles.

People "said" he was good due to Makelele cleaning up after him. Thats bollocks, sure it allowed him more freedom to attack but he still done his defensive work. Not to mention Makelele didnt play as often last season while Essien was in various roles.

Just another Chelsea/Lamps hater. I might hate Liverpool myself, but i give credit when due to the likes of Gerrard and Carra.
[/rant]

Over:
Rooney
Carrick
Robinson
Nani
Walcott
Lennon
Torres
Reina
Downing


Under:
Carvalho
Tiago
Rosina
Finnan
Suazo
Maresca
Kalou
Solano
Given
Cisse
Carra
Woodgate

[fanutd]

overrated
chelsea and liverpool

underrated
sunderland